This is odd - I’ve had a G1 for a little over a week - and I’m generally not loving it. Now its a great start for a platform - but the hardware is poor - battery life makes it unreliable as a medium use handset (forget heavy use). At least you can carry a spare (not currently available though - other than dodgy ebay ones). For me the G1 and N96 are two very very different phones. If the N96 had solid firmware it would trounce the G1 - but it doesn’t which makes life more complicated.
The G1 feels fresh - even in post iPhone expectations. But its just lacking that certain - useful ness. The App Store Android Market has nothing of real use to me. Nokia download may be pants - but at least nokia have tons of genuinely useful software to add to you N-series phone. These will come to android in time - but at the moment its missing core functionality. Video is uncatered for - I have a big lovely screen and no way of reliably watching video content - or creating any. The music player should be filed under ‘functional’ but is best avoided as it drains the battery quicker than you can say ‘kylie’s gold hot pants’.
G1 does email and cloud syncing better than ever - without the mobile me style disasters. The keyboard makes replying to emails a joy - but at a cost - even sending a short sms requires you to flop out the keyboard and jump into two handed mode. A virtual keyboard option is essential in the future (esp as some android phones will presumable have no physical QWERTY or keypad - like the rumoured touch HD with android).
Of course the physical and functional elements of these devices is nothing without a seemless, fast and pragmatic operating system/software combination. Nokia really need to follow google/yahoo and apples lead on a single user login for all services.
So the big question - which would I keep if I could only have one. Surprisingly I would plump for the N96. Though neither is an ideal choice - we’re in a post iPhone drought of inspring handsets - and I am confident 2009 is going to start with a bang (5th edition S60 phones -N97? N98? iPhone v3, RIM seem to be hitting the smart/consumer market rather than just the suits and some serious Android handsets).
Well there has been alot of fanboy nonsense about the N85 being the new world order - it seems initial reviews are less than complimentary. Hey guess what, a cheaper device has poorer build quality - what a shocker!!!
I suspect some re-evaluation and slight improved attitudes towards the N96, but I can’t help thinking neither is a long term product, and theres much more to come.